2008-2009 handbook PDF
version or .doc
version.
LSTA/Oregon Association of School Libraries
Oregon Battle of the Books
2007-2008 Handbook
State Chair:
Deborah Alvarez
State Committee Members:
Allen Kopf
Diane Chaffee
JaKay Greer
Barbara Gutzler
Libby Hamler-Dupras
Angela Hatfield
Lynda Johnston
Judy Kulluson
Christina Larrechea
Jan Nichols
Mary McClintock
DeAnn Orand
Karen Osborne
B.J. Quinlan
Ann Sindelar-Trahin
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction
History
Organization
Player and Team Guidelines
Coach Guidelines and Responsibilities
Battle Procedures
Battle Officials
FAQs
Criteria for the Selection of
Titles
Writing and Submitting Questions
Promotional Ideas
How to Manage Public Relations
Introduction
The Oregon Battle of the Books is a statewide reading motivation and
comprehension program sponsored by the Oregon Association of School Libraries
in conjunction with a Library Services and Technology Act grant. Students, regardless
of ability, are exposed to quality literature representing a variety of literary
styles and viewpoints. The goals of the program are to encourage and recognize
students who enjoy reading, broaden reading interests, increase reading comprehension,
and promote academic excellence.
Lists of books are chosen and questions are written for elementary and middle
school. Students read the books, discuss them, quiz each other on the contents,
and then compete in teams of four students to correctly answer questions based
on the books in a "quiz show" format. Questions may begin with the words "In
which book..." so that the answer will be a title and author or it may be a content
question with the title of the book supplied. Teams may participate at local,
district, regional and state levels of competition.
New lists of recommended titles for each level are compiled each year by the
selection committee based on the "Criteria for the Selection of Titles." An attempt
is made to vary the titles chosen according to genre and difficulty so that readers
may encounter a broad range of books.
History
The original idea for Battle of the Books came from a radio program sponsored
by the Chicago Public Library in the early 1940's. Prior to 2006, several schools
in Oregon had their own Battle of the Books competitions. In 2006, OASL President
Allen Kopf formed a committee to submit a grant to LSTA for a statewide Battle
of the Books program. Upon receipt of the grant, the committee moved forward
with the statewide plan to be implemented in the 2007-2008 school year.
Organization
Oregon Battle of the Books is organized locally by the participating
school system, regionally (OASL Regions) by a regional committee, and statewide
by the OASL Oregon Battle of the Books Committee (OBOB).
The OBOB Committee will oversee the collection and distribution of information,
questions, and book lists. At this time, the OASL OBOB Committee is assuming
regional committees will be responsible for the regional competitions, while
the OBOB Committee will oversee the state competition.
Player and Team Guidelines
- All students participating must be in grades 3-5 or 6-9 for the current
school year.
- Each team must have a sponsor from their school who is a school library
media specialist, library paraprofessional or other school staff member.
- The composition of the team members may not change once the regional battles
have started.
- The regional competition do not require participation in a district/county/ESD
competition. The state battles require participation in the regional competitions.
- Each school may send only one team to the regional competition (grant recipients
must attend the regional competitions) and each region may send their top
two teams to the state competition.
- Teams are usually made up of four members with one optional alternate,
for a total of five members.
- There may be only one alternate. This alternate may take the place of a
player for a battle. When the alternate is used, the alternate must remain
in competition for the entire battle. No other substitutions may be made.
- No other person may assist in answering any question directed to a team,
including the team’s coach. The judge will disqualify a team determined
to be receiving outside help.
- In the event of a situation that is not specifically addressed in the OBOB
rules, the decision of the judges is final.
- The OBOB Committee has the authority to refuse to allow a team to participate
in the event of un-sportsmanlike behavior or other extenuating circumstances.
Coach Guidelines and Responsibilities
- Prepare the teams by reviewing procedures and rules.
- Conduct practice battles which follow OBOB protocol.
- Encourage and moderate discussions about the books.
- Direct teams in writing their own practice questions if additional questions
are desired.
- Offer moral support to teams during Battles without actually offering any
input to help them with their answers.
- Must secure adult supervision for the team at all regional and state competitions.
- Reinforce that the focus of this program is to celebrate the love of reading
and promote good sportsmanship for both teams and spectators.
Regional and State Battle Procedures:
- The following must be available for each battle:
- A packet of OBOB questions
- A copy of each of the OBOB Battle Books
- A copy of the Official Book List
- A copy of the Official Handbook
- A coin for the coin toss
- Sufficient score sheets
- A stopwatch and clipboard
- Teams are usually made up of four members with one optional alternate,
for a total of five members. Of the four competing members, one will serve
as the spokesperson throughout each battle.
- Two teams will compete during a single battle. Efforts will be made to
assure teams can quietly discuss answers among themselves without fear of
being overheard by the other competing team(s).
- A coin toss will be held before the start of each battle. The winning team
decides where they want to sit. The team that sits on the left will be always
be given first chance at the odd numbered questions, and the team on the
right will always be given first chance at the even questions.
- The Moderator/Reader will review the rules with the participating teams
and find out who is serving as the Spokespersons.
- The Moderator/Reader will accept answers from only that Spokesperson; no
other team member's answer shall be heard and recorded during that battle.
- The "odd" team (on the Moderator/Reader's left) will go first and be read
question number one.
- The Moderator/Reader will ask a question, prefacing the question with the
name of the team it is directed to. Timing starts immediately after
the question has been read for the first time. Teams will use the allotted
time to quietly discuss the question among themselves. The team will have
15 seconds in which to discuss and answer the question. Only the first answer
the Spokesperson gives will be acceptable--the team cannot use up the time
left to guess other titles.
- During battle, a team’s spokesperson may request a repeat of a question.
All repeats must take place within the time limit, which starts after the
question is read for the first time.
- Discussion must stop as soon as time is called, the question must then
be answered immediately.
- In the "In which book" questions, if the title is correct, the team is
awarded 3 points. An additional 2 points shall be awarded for the correct
author (both first and last names, as listed on the official OBOB book lists).
- If a team gives an incorrect title or author, the opposing team may pick
up points for title (3 points), or author (2 points), or both. The question
will be repeated to the "acquiring" team, which will then have 15 seconds
in which to come up with their answer. NOTE: If the acquiring team does not
answer correctly, play does NOT pass back to the other team.
- In the "open response" questions, 5 points are given for the correct answer.
- If a team gives an incorrect answer, the opposing team may pick up the
points by answering correctly (5 points).
- Regardless of who scored what on the last question, even numbered questions
will be read to the even team, and odd numbered questions will be read to
the odd team. This means that an "acquiring" team will get to answer two
questions in a row--the one it acquired, followed by their own.
- If a team has begun its response before time is called, it will be allowed
to complete it.
- At the end of a battle, the Moderator/Reader must allow 15 seconds for
challenges to be articulated through the team's spokesperson only. If there
are no challenges, the final score will be announced and a winner will be
declared. The battle will be considered complete and no further challenges
will be entertained. The teams will be sent on to their next battle.
- An answer is considered correct even if mispronounced, as long as the judge
can discern it. Correct titles and authors are those listed as they appear
on the official OBOB book list. No points will be given for a partial title
or if only the last name of the author is listed. Multiple questions may
appear on certain titles and some titles may not be asked about at all. Teams
may not use a title/author list or any notes.
- In the event of a CHALLENGE, this procedure will be followed:
- The challenging team will have TWO minutes to find and mark the page numbers
(with a post-it note) where the answer can be found in the book they named.
- The timekeeper will begin timing after the Moderator/Reader recognizes
the challenge and copies of the book are given to the challenging team.
- When time is called, discussion must stop.
- The official timer will announce only the end of the TWO minute time period.
- The challenging team should be able to provide exact reference to a page
in the book so the judge can refer to the correct passage.
- The judge determines whether the challenge is successful or not. An answer
may be considered correct by way of inference. If the judge accepts the challenge
as successful, and the other conditions for gaining a score were fulfilled,
the points shall be awarded and the scores amended.
- The judge’s decision is final.
- At the regional and state competitions, a tiebreaker battle may be played
to break a tie between two or more teams. The tiebreaker rules are the same
as above. As soon as one team has more points after at least two questions
are answered, that team is declared the winner. If the score is still tied
after 10 tiebreaker questions, the official may call a tie. Challenges ARE
allowed at the end of tiebreaker battle with the usual challenge time in
effect.
Battle Officials
- Moderator/Reader
- Reviews rules and expectations.
- Will read questions and run the Battle.
- If a question is misread at the regional or state competitions, a new
question may be given.
- At the end of a battle, the Moderator/Reader will ask the scorekeeper
to verify the final score with the Judge and then take it to the OBOB official
in charge.
- Scorekeeper
- Will keep the official score on a visual projection device or chalk/whiteboard,
in a way which is visible to the audience.
- Timekeeper
- Oversees coin toss.
- Will use a stopwatch and indicate when specific time periods have expired.
- Judge
- Will determine if the correct answer has been given within the prescribed
time limit.
- Keeps a paper copy of the scores.
- Will make certain no help on answers to the questions is given by others
outside the team.
- Will hear any complaint issued in an approved manner, confer with any
and all appropriate officials, and render judgment on the matter.
- Once the judge's decision is stated, the battle shall resume.
- The judge’s decision shall be final.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Do non-grant schools who participate in OBOB have to furnish a certain
number of books to their students?
- How does a student participate?
- A student participates by reading from the book list provided for that
year's Oregon Battle of the Books and discussing those titles and competing
in battles with their teammates.
- Where do the students get the books?
- School libraries should have copies of each book on the list. Public
libraries and local book stores will also be apprised of the titles
and will most likely have them available.
- For the first two years only, schools may apply for book funding through
the LSTA grant.
- When do the students read the books?
- The school battles should be completed by the end of February. Reading
through the summer is completely optional, but available to students. Students
should have plenty of time to read the books during the school year.
- What Is a "Battle?"
- A typical "Battle" is a tournament or game, somewhat like Jeopardy, in
which students' teams earn points by answering questions about the books
on the book list.
- Can we change our district team after the district battle? Can we add or
change members?
- Your 5 member team, (4 members and alternate) may not change after the
names have been sent in to the Regional Coordinator as listed on the OBOB
website.
- Team names need to be submitted to the regional coordinator two weeks
prior
- When is it OK for alternates to participate in the regional/state level
competition?
- An alternate may only replace a team member between Battles, never during
a battle.
- Players may not be substituted once a Battle has begun EXCEPT in the
event of an illness or emergency.
- Do students have to read all the books?
- No. Most students read only about half of the books. There are a few
readers who complete the whole list, but there are some who might only
be able to read five of the books.
- Do I need other schools to have a battle or can I just have only one at
my school?
- It is best to start small. The first time you conduct a battle, we recommend
that you do it alone at your school site. However, it is always good to
have other schools in your district or in your area conduct their own battles.
- How do I get started?
- A place to start is by joining OASL (go to our website: www.oasl.info)!
Have your school purchase books from the book list and develop an in-house
reading incentive system to encourage students to read these books. Request
questions for your competition (via our website) and begin to find sponsors
and helpers to support and conduct your local battle at your site or region.
- May I use the OBOB logo?
- The logo is available for any Oregon Battle of the Books promotional
activity, with the proviso that the Oregon Association of School Libraries
must be given credit for their sponsorship.
- Should the logo be used by any commercial entity, the sponsorship credit
must be printed somewhere on the same page on which the logo is used.
- Who else is participating in Oregon?
- Participants are listed on the OBOB website.
- Who can I contact to get help with how to get started and answer many of
my questions?
- You can call one of the OBOB participants in your area.
- Do we need to have awards for the winning teams?
- We suggest that you find ways to honor all participants.
- Why didn't I hear about this sooner?
- The OBOB committee has disseminated information as quickly as possible
in this, our first year. Information is posted on our OASL and OBOB websites
and on our OASL listserv. If you have questions, please contact us!
Criteria for the selection
of titles
- Number of titles:
- Grade level/reading level:
- Balanced grade / reading level.
- Interest level:
- Consider a variety of subject areas, plots, settings and styles.
- Balanced in interest for boys and girls.
- List must include a variety of genres, including realistic fiction, nonfiction,
fantasy, science fiction, historical fiction, mystery, multicultural, and
Oregon represented in some way.
- Quality of the books:
- Select high quality, well-reviewed, age-appropriate titles.
- Award winners such as the Newbery, Young Readers Choice, etc., will be
considered.
- Books on previous lists:
- Titles may have been used as OBOB titles previously.
- However, titles must not be repeated within at least four years of being
on the list.
- Availability of titles:
- Books should be currently available in paperback format whenever possible.
- Intellectual freedom:
- In accordance with the Library Bill of Rights and its interpretations,
titles that otherwise meet the selection criteria will not be excluded:
- "because of the origin, background or views of those contributing to
their creation," or
- "because of partisan or doctrinal disapproval;" or
- "because of actual or suspected parental objections" or
- "in an effort to avoid controversy with parents."
- Other considerations:
- It must be kept in mind that the Oregon Battle of the Books is not meant
to be a required program in the schools. A child's participation is voluntary.
This being the case, it should be expected that different criteria are
used for the selection of these titles than those used in selecting materials
for required activities in individual school districts.
Writing and Submitting Questions
After the book list is finalized, titles are assigned to individuals or
groups who write the questions. Completed sets of questions must be submitted
to the OBOB Committee by AUGUST 15 so they can be edited and made available
to districts in a timely manner.
Writing the Questions
- Please write 40-60 questions per book:
- 1/3 will be used at the local school level
- 1/3 will be used at the Regional level.
- 1/3 will be used at the State level.
- Begin half of the questions with, "In which book...", the other half will
state the title and ask a specific content question.
- Open response questions should have a single answer.
- Try to limit questions to a maximum of twenty words each, including the
words "In which book".
- When citing page #s, use the edition which is listed on the Official Title
List. (It is vital that the answer can be verified in the event of a challenge.)
- Use correct grammar. It is not acceptable to say "In which book does a
character ride their horse?"
- Avoid indicating the gender of the character if possible. Do not use the
he/she pronoun, instead, reword the sentence (i.e. "In which book does a
character ride a horse?" or "... is a horse ridden by its owner?"
- Make the question as direct as possible using archaic and unique words
only when they appear in the book and are necessary to the clarity of the
question.
- Use the present tense in reference to the time of the story as much as
possible (does/do or is/are).
- Avoid obvious questions.
- Do not use key words from the title.
- Avoid questions whose answers might easily be found in more than one book.
- Use direct quotes only when they are an integral part of the story - for
example, a phrase repeated throughout the book.
- If direct quotes are used, make sure they are unedited!
- Try to avoid "killer" questions. (These are questions that require a photographic
memory.)
- Try to cover:
- Significant events
- Character development
- Major themes
- Unique settings in time or place
Submitting the Questions
- Do not number the questions. Numbering creates formatting problems when
compiling the questions.
- Please do not use other colors than black and do not underline or highlight.
- Questions should be in a format that is easily copied into a database.
The following format is acceptable:
Type out questions with a tab in between. The question
would then read:
In which book does a couple celebrate their honeymoon by driving around a grandstand
track several times? Journey to Topaz by Yoshiko Uchida p. 68 Grade 6-9
- The question committee will determine what level of battle the question
will be used in. After the final formatting, a typical question will look
like this:
In which book does a couple celebrate
their honeymoon by driving around a grandstand track several times?
Journey to Topaz by Yoshiko Uchida
p. 68 Grade 6-9 REGIONAL
2007 Oregon Battle of the Books
- Please proofread your work before you send it in. You will know more about
that particular title than almost anyone else. Then have someone else proofread
it for grammar, readability, etc.
Promotional
Ideas
A wide variety of ideas have been submitted for promoting the program
and motivating students to read. Several ideas are outlined below.
Involve parents, teachers, administrators and the public as much as
possible.
Use video recordings from Battles in previous years.
Purchase or rent media versions of the Battle books.
Do group orientations for students, staff and parents.
Do book talks using Battle books.
Make bookmarks from each levels official book list.
Organize bookmark contests with students.
Design visible displays or bulletin boards publicizing the program.
Saturate school bulletins, district newsletters, and other handouts with program
information.
Encourage teachers to read books or portions of books aloud to students.
Hold contests to redesign book covers, design a school logo for Battle of the
Books, prepare for the toughest questions, etc.
Have students create large posters of book covers to display.
Develop a variety of study guides or literature units related to the Battle books
that include games, crossword puzzles, "first line" quizzes, etc.
Create a large display including title/author lists, participants names, and
places to chart each student’s progress.
Hold a party or a library sleep-over for students who read all of the books on
their list.
The list is only limited by your own creativity and time! Students who participate
in the Oregon Battle of the Books are usually easy to motivate and are enthusiastic.
(Do not forget to save a copy of everything you do as a guide for next year).
How to Manage Public Relations
The real key to a publicity campaign is planning. Keep a schedule
or time line for yourself as a reminder of when to notify the parents of impending
competitions, when to call the media, when to submit newsletters for district
publications, when to bring in your camera to record momentous events, etc. Please
include in publicity items that the Oregon Battle of the Books is sponsored by
the Oregon Association of School Libraries.
Local newspapers, local radio and television stations, as well as statewide publications,
are anxious to read and hear about what is occurring in the schools. Even if
you have to take the pictures and write the articles, record the interviews,
or set up the video gear yourself, it will be worth the effort. Communications
with the parents and the community about this popular school program will also
open channels that can later be utilized when support for this and other worthy
programs may be needed.
Do a presentation on the Battle of the Books for open house.
Get local merchants to display not only the books, but also rules and prizes.
Sends out regular letters to parents, as well as news releases.
Send individual invitations to school board and city council members to attend
Oregon Battle of the Books finals in their communities. (Also, invite school
board/city council members to be officials!)
The Oregon Battle of the Books Committee will be keeping historical data and
will be in contact with the media. Please send digital photographs as well as
local news reports to the Oregon Battle of the Books Chair for use in statewide
publicity.
Just remember to communicate with those around you who might otherwise miss out
on important events. Also, save everything you do - every invitation you send,
every letter home, every news item, every photo you take, every time line you
prepare. You may wish to reuse items, or remind yourself about ideas from year
to year. |